As the owner of Sheenu Game Center, a gaming hub that has been thriving for the past 18 years, I’ve witnessed the evolution of gaming technology firsthand. Recently, I had the opportunity to test a 15-year-old PlayStation 2 (PS2) controller, and what I discovered was astonishing: despite years of heavy use and a considerable amount of dirt buildup, this controller exhibited almost zero stick drift.

For those unfamiliar, stick drift is a common issue in modern gaming controllers where the analog sticks register movement without any input from the player. This problem has become increasingly prevalent with contemporary controllers, including the PlayStation 5’s DualSense. It got me thinking: why did we rarely, if ever, hear about stick drift during the PS2 era, despite analog sticks being a staple feature since the PlayStation 1 days?

To understand this, let’s delve into my experience and observations.

The Experiment

I recently acquired a PS2-to-PC USB hub and decided to test the old PS2 controller out of sheer curiosity. Given its age and the extensive use it has seen at my gaming center, I expected it to have significant wear and tear. To my surprise, the controller performed exceptionally well, with no noticeable stick drift. This starkly contrasts with modern controllers, which often exhibit drift after just a few months of use.

To further validate my findings, I tested the controller on multiple platforms. Using hardwaretester.com, it was detected as an “XInput Compatible HID Device.” I also used Windows’ own gamepad tester, where it was recognized as a “DS3 Compatible HID Device.” Both tests confirmed the controller’s excellent condition and lack of stick drift, even after 15 years of heavy usage.

To illustrate this point, I conducted a comparative test and captured the results in the following image. The image shows the 15-year-old PS2 controller being tested for stick drift, and as expected, it showed almost no signs of drift. The contrast is striking and highlights the issue perfectly.

The Material Difference

One key reason for this longevity lies in the quality of materials used in older controllers. During the PS2 era, manufacturers prioritized durability and performance, using high-quality components that could withstand years of heavy usage. Today, despite controllers being more expensive than ever, the focus seems to have shifted towards cost-cutting measures, leading to the use of cheaper materials that are more prone to wear and tear.

The Hall Effect Debate

There has been much discussion about how Hall Effect sensors could potentially solve the stick drift issue. These sensors are more durable and precise because they use magnetic fields to detect stick movement, reducing physical contact and therefore wear. We previously discussed the potential of Hall Effect sensors in detail (article link).

However, even without such advanced technology, the simple use of higher-quality parts in analog sticks could significantly reduce the prevalence of stick drift. It’s not just about using the latest technology but about ensuring that the components used are built to last.

The DualSense Controllers

Take the DualSense controllers, for instance. Despite being lauded for their innovative features like adaptive triggers and haptic feedback, they are not immune to stick drift. Many users have reported issues within just a few months of use, which is disappointing considering the premium price tag. Even the DualSense Edge, the elite version of the controller, suffers the same fate. This indicates that the problem is not limited to the standard model but is prevalent across different variations of the controller.

As a genuine seller, it feels really disheartening to see so many customers face this issue just a few months, if not days, after purchasing a new controller. This was not the case in the PS2 days, or even with PS3 controllers, which were far less prone to this issue. It’s a clear indication of how the quality of materials and manufacturing standards have declined over the years. Below is the image of stick drift on a DualSense controller that is just two months old. 

Conclusion

My experience with the 15-year-old PS2 controller is a testament to the fact that good quality materials and robust manufacturing processes can lead to a product that stands the test of time. As gaming technology continues to evolve, it’s crucial for manufacturers like Sony, Microsoft and Nintendo to strike a balance between innovation and durability. While Hall Effect sensors might be a part of the solution, simply investing in better quality materials for analog sticks could also go a long way in addressing the stick drift issue.

In an era where gaming accessories are more expensive than ever, gamers deserve products that not only offer cutting-edge features but also last for years without compromising on performance. It’s high time for companies to revisit the manufacturing standards of the past and ensure that the controllers of today and tomorrow are built to endure the test of time.

By sharing these images and my personal experience, I hope to shed light on the importance of quality manufacturing in gaming accessories and encourage a shift back towards durability and reliability in the industry.

If you’re interested in starting your own gaming business, I’ve written an eBook that shares insights and experiences from my 18 years in the industry. It’s now available on Amazon, and purchasing it is a great way to support me and gain valuable knowledge for your own venture.